Method

Every entry on this site rests on a printed book that you can open and check. This page says which book, how a name becomes an entry, and what is checked before a page goes out.

1. The source

So far we use one book: Charles ffoulkes, Armour & Weapons, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1909. It is out of copyright and its plain-text edition is Project Gutenberg ebook #41676. We keep a local copy of that text and record its SHA-256 checksum, 9f9bf64f560026f07bb4fa2bcbab081f94a40141a2c73fcfa070184e687c66aa. If the copy changes by even one character, the build stops.

We do not use other websites, museum catalogues or encyclopaedias for the content of an entry. Each entry says which chapter of that book it quotes.

2. How a name becomes an entry

A name gets an entry only if it appears in the text of the book. The entry then marks the chapter where we found it. A name that is only a modern collectors’ label, and is not in the book, does not get an entry. Where the book gives several names for one piece (the soleret and the sabaton), they sit on one page. Where the book treats a group of weapons together, as it does with the long-shafted staff weapons, they sit on one page too.

3. Spelling

The book spells some words in ways that differ from today’s: halbard for halberd, heaume for helm, chain-mail with a hyphen. Inside a quotation we keep the book’s spelling exactly. In our own sentences we use the heading spelling and say when the book writes it differently. We do not merge two names unless the book itself says they are the same.

4. Dates

A date on this site is a date the book gives, worded as the book words it, such as “the twelfth century” or “1443”. If the book gives none, the entry says so. We do not fill gaps from memory or from other websites. The book may be out of date on some points, since it was printed in 1909, and later research may differ from it.

5. Quotations

Each entry quotes one or two sentences, each at most 40 words, copied from the book with the chapter marked. We choose sentences that name or describe a piece. We do not quote sentences about how a piece was used, how much it could withstand, or fighting.

6. Checks that run before a page is published

  • Every quotation must be found word for word in the local copy of the book, ignoring only line breaks and extra spaces. A quotation that differs by a single word stops the build.
  • A quotation of more than 40 words, or one with no chapter label, or one marked with the wrong chapter, stops the build.
  • A quotation containing words about striking, piercing, wounding, fighting and the like stops the build.
  • Every other name and date shown on a page must also be found in the book, and a year or century written in our own text must match one the page took from the book.
  • After the pages are built, the quotations in the finished pages are checked against the book again, and each page must carry its source block.

7. What we leave out

How armour or weapons were made, sharpened or repaired; how to use them; what they are worth; and the law on owning them. This is a reference for names, appearance and dates as an old book records them.

8. Automated requests

When our tools fetch a text from a remote server, the request says who it is from and points to this page. We follow that server’s robots.txt rules and wait between requests.

9. Corrections

Write to the address on the About page with the page address and the place in the book you checked. We check it against the book, fix the entry, and keep the “Checked” date in its source block up to date.